I don't know how many years passed after 1941 before they made a movie about Pearl Harbour, and I don't know how long after 1963 it was before someone first dramatized Kennedy's assassination. I don't know how much time the collective psyche needs before they can feel a sense of detached distance as they watch a tragedy re-created on the big screen. I don't know if the profusion of "reality" TV shows or 24-hour news coverage has brought us to expect, and even accept, that sense of "right here, right now" as events unfold.
But having seen United 93 this evening, I can tell you this about the horror of September 11, 2001 - four and half years is not long enough. Not for me, anyway.
Supposedly, I, like many millions of others, have become somewhat numb after viewing days, weeks and months of TV footage and newspaper photos from 9/11. Add to that the fact that I am A) not American, and B) connected in no way "personally" to the tragedies that occurred that day. The video footage of the second plane hitting the towers - how many times have I seen it? A dozen? A hundred? Probably more. I watched it, then, and since, again and again, each time with a sense of dumbfounded yet detached horror. A feeling of "this can't be happening, but it is, and it did."
Tonight, that exact same footage - the exact same - was like a blow to the head. Tears came to my eyes, I gulped for breath, and ultimately, had to leave the theatre for a moment, it was so unsettling.
That alone makes me say the movie was well done.
Like The Passion of the Christ, this isn't the type of movie that I think you can call "good" or "bad." It was horrifying. Overwhelming. Intense. But this isn't your standard disaster movie, or even, in my opinion, a glamourous, romanticized re-creation. It is chaotic, and bloody, and tragic. There are no stars, but they are all heroes - doomed, yet successful in their mission. It couldn't have been anything else.
So well done, that yes, I was on the edge of my seat at times, knowing the ending was inevitable, yet hoping, somehow, some way, this would end differently. You want this to be another Towering Inferno, or Poseidon, or even Pearl Harbour, where someone, even just one of the good guys, emerges from the ashes at the end.
9/11, on most days, for me, seems like yesterday and yet a lifetime ago. I haven't seen a blue sky since that I've felt a complete sense of peace and predictability. But I've flown since, too, and not felt afraid. Watching United 93 tonight helped me to realize that though it all seems a long time ago, it hasn't been nearly as long as it usually feels.
Certainly not long enough.